The new series 'Monsters,' which delves into the infamous Menendez brothers case, is stirring up significant controversy. Critics have voiced concerns over the portrayal of Erik and Lyle Menendez, who were convicted of murdering their wealthy parents in 1989. The show has sparked discussions about sensationalism and the ethics of dramatizing such a tragic event.
- Netflix has premiered the show 'Monsters'
- It details the Menendez brothers' muders
- THIS is the criticism from one of them
The ire from within
Erik Menendez, now 52, has spoken out regarding the series, expressing his feelings about the way the story has been depicted. In interviews, he emphasized the need for a more nuanced understanding of the complex factors that led to the murders, including the abuse the brothers endured.
He argues that these critical aspects of their lives are often overshadowed by the sensational elements of the case, reducing their story to mere entertainment.
Actor Nicholas Alexander Chavez said: "I can only respond with sympathy and empathy in that I can only imagine how difficult it is to have the most traumatic moment of your life put up there on the screen for everyone to see," he told 'USA TODAY.'
Chavez also said that his research for 'Monsters' was "extensive" and involved reviewing documentaries and books about the Menéndez brothers, as well as watching court TV footage from the time.
"With the court TV footage, you're getting a glimpse into what was happening in that time, but the show aims to fill out a lot more details than just the courtroom scenes," he said. "So that makes it interesting."
Shortly after the debut of 'Monsters,' Erik Menéndez slammed the show for its "horrible and blatant lies" in a statement issued by his wife. "I can only believe they were done so on purpose," he said. "It is with a heavy heart that I say, I believe Ryan Murphy cannot be this naive and inaccurate about the facts of our lives so as to do this without bad intent."
Some viewers have taken issue with the series appearing to float the idea that the Menéndez brothers may have been in an incestuous relationship. The two brothers kiss on the lips in one scene, while another moment shows their mother walking in on them showering together.
The series aims to explore not only the infamous crime but also the broader implications of family dynamics, trauma, and the justice system. However, many believe that it risks trivializing the deep emotional scars left by the events. Critics argue that focusing on the sensational aspects could lead to a distorted view of the brothers and their motivations.
In response to the backlash, the show’s creators have defended their approach. They assert that their intention is not to glorify the crime but to provide insight into the psychological complexities surrounding it. They believe that by highlighting the brothers’ backstory, the series can contribute to a deeper conversation about the consequences of abuse and the challenges faced by those who endure it.
Also interesting:
Amidst team drama
Martha's wrath
As the series continues to air, it remains to be seen how audiences will react to its portrayal of such a fraught subject. Erik Menendez's response underscores the ongoing debate about the responsibility of filmmakers in depicting real-life tragedies.
The conversation surrounding 'Monsters' highlights the tension between storytelling and sensitivity, raising important questions about how we engage with true crime narratives.
