- Hall & Oates are fighting in court
- New filings have been obtained
- THIS is what Hall has said about Oates
The airwaves are crackling with news of "the ultimate partnership betrayal" as Hall accuses Oates of a sneaky move to sell off half of their shared empire, Whole Oats Enterprises LLP. This company isn't just any old business; it's the heart of their musical legacy, holding the keys to their trademarks, personal names, and even their social media swagger!
Legal Docs Drop Like Chart-Topping Hits
Wednesday was a day of declarations, with Hall dropping a bombshell claim that Oates was playing a solo act in their partnership, trying to maintain ownership of Whole Oats Enterprises LLP under false pretenses. Hall's declaration paints a picture of "tremendous upheaval" and "unnecessary expense," while Oates fires back, claiming it's all a bunch of sour notes.
Hall is claiming Oates attempted to sell his stake in the venture to Primary Wave Music, a New York company with a focus on marketing estates and song catalogs. Hall's legal representatives sought to stop Oates from advancing any sale, and on November 30, a judge agreed to block the deal until an arbitrator settles the dispute, or until February 17.
"I am deeply troubled by the deterioration of my relationship with, and trust in, John Oates," Hall wrote in a court filing, referring to the feud as the "ultimate partnership betrayal."
Oates's lawyer, Tim Warnock, defended his client's actions, contending that he proceeded within his rights.
Some of the Hall and Oates' catalog is already tied up with Primary Wave. The company previously acquired interests from the songwriters Sara and Janna Allen, integral to some of Hall & Oates's most significant works.
The drama hit a crescendo last week as Hall slapped a temporary restraining order on Oates, citing a "contract/debt" dispute that had Nashville's chancery court buzzing. The case was sealed tighter than their hit records, leaving fans in suspense until this week's revelations.
The nature of the dispute between Daryl Hall and John Oates, which had been obscured in sealed court documents, became clearer on Thursday as one of pop music’s most recognizable and long-running duos put their fight in front of a judge in Nashville.
Details of the collapse of the 50-year artistic collaboration and business partnership between the two had been trickling out for days in court papers submitted before Thursday’s hearing in Chancery Court, where Hall and Oates were represented by lawyers but did not appear.
At Thursday’s hearing, Tim Warnock, a lawyer for Oates, denied that his client was making a deal behind Hall's back. "Mr. Oates has proceeded exactly as he was allowed to proceed,” he said. "Mr. Hall could have done the exact same thing himself."
Also interesting:
Lawyers for Oates have asserted that the dispute should be solved in arbitration, arguing that Hall created the time pressure on himself by waiting nearly three weeks to bring the case to arbitrators.
"Any adverse consequence based on the passage of time is a problem of Plaintiffs’ own making," they wrote.
These two music maestros first joined forces in the '60s and soared to stardom with a string of hits that became the soundtrack of the '80s. But now, their harmony is facing the music in a courtroom battle that's more gripping than a Hall & Oates chorus!
Stay tuned as we keep you in the loop with every twist and turn of this rock 'n' roll legal saga!