Disney has decided to cut a transgender storyline from its upcoming animated series 'Win or Lose,' sparking controversy and debate. The decision comes amidst political pressures and a focus on entertainment over messaging. Disney CEO Bob Iger emphasizes the company's primary goal is to entertain, not to promote specific agendas.
- Disney removes a transgender storyline
- Disney's stance on diversity is revisited
- They are losing too much money
Disney's Approach to Diversity
Disney has made a significant decision to remove a transgender storyline from its new animated series, 'Win or Lose,' before its release on Disney+ on February 19.
The series, produced by Pixar, follows a middle school softball team, the Pickles, with each episode focusing on a different character. Despite the removal of the storyline, the character associated with it will remain. This decision was reportedly made months ago, but it is not as simple as editing a script since the character's dialogue had already been recorded.
Disney stated, "When it comes to animated content for a younger audience, we recognize that many parents would prefer to discuss certain subjects with their children on their own terms and timeline."
The announcement of the storyline removal follows the reelection of former President Donald Trump, who has been vocal against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. Many companies have recently adjusted their DEI policies in response to online pressure and threats.
When asked about Disney's decision potentially signaling a shift away from diversity initiatives, the company opted not to comment. Earlier this year, Disney CEO Bob Iger expressed that the entertainment giant is not focused on sending messages in its productions.
He stated, "The term woke is thrown around rather liberally... infusing messaging as a sort of a number one priority in our films and TV shows is not what we’re up to. They need to be entertaining."
Political Influence on Entertainment
Disney's history with diverse storylines has been contentious. The 2022 'Toy Story' prequel 'Lightyear' included a same-sex relationship and kiss, which was initially cut but later restored after backlash.
The film faced criticism from conservatives and was banned in several countries. Disney has also featured LGBTQ representation in adult-oriented content like FX's 'Pose' and Marvel's 'Agatha All Along.' After Florida's "Don't Say Gay" law in 2022, Disney faced backlash for its stance against the legislation, with right-wing media portraying the company as promoting an LGBTQ agenda.
In his return as Disney's chief, Iger has emphasized that creators should focus on entertainment rather than rights advocacy. Speaking at the DealBook Summit, he reiterated, "When I came back, what I’ve really tried to do is to return to our roots — which is, remember, we have to entertain first: It’s not about messages.
In recent years, Disney has also pushed for more inclusivity through its live-action remakes, including 'Beauty and the Beast', which featured a gay character in the form of "LeFou," played by Josh Gad.
Although the portrayal was brief and subtle, it marked a step toward LGBTQ+ representation in Disney films. In 2020, Disney’s first openly gay character, "LeFou," appeared in 'Onward', a Pixar film, where the character’s sexuality was casually mentioned in a small, but important moment.
However, many fans and activists argue that these representations still fall short of what is truly needed in terms of LGBTQ+ visibility, with many inclusivity moments being treated as secondary or hidden in the background. Despite this, Disney's efforts in this area are viewed as steps toward greater LGBTQ+ representation in family-friendly media.
Disney continues to make strides in diversifying its stories and characters, but the path forward remains a work in progress. As society evolves, so too does the demand for more authentic, inclusive portrayals of marginalized communities in entertainment. The conversations about racial representation, gender equality, and LGBTQ+ inclusion continue to shape the way Disney approaches its films.
The success of films like 'Black Panther' and 'The Woman King', which showcase African and African American cultures, highlights the audience’s hunger for diverse and authentic representation.
At the same time, the increasing involvement of diverse filmmakers, writers, and artists behind the scenes has the potential to further transform the way Disney tells stories. The company’s focus on telling stories that reflect the complexities of human identity, culture, and experience means that inclusivity will continue to be a driving force in shaping Disney’s future films.
Their journey toward inclusivity has been marked by incremental steps and, at times, significant leaps forward.
From early films that mostly reflected Western ideals to modern films that embrace a broad spectrum of cultures, identities, and backgrounds, Disney has responded to both internal and external pressures to become a more inclusive and diverse force in the entertainment industry.
Also interesting:
Exciting times
While there are still challenges to overcome and many stories yet to be told, Disney's evolving approach to inclusivity shows that the company is committed to creating films that reflect the world’s diversity, ensuring that audiences of all backgrounds can see themselves represented on screen.
